The leading experimental determinations of the fine-structure constant πΌ currently rely on atomic photon-recoil measurements from Ramsey-BordΓ© atom interferometry with large-momentum transfer to provide an absolute mass measurement. We propose an experimental scheme for an intermediate-scale differential atom interferometer to measure the photon recoil of neutral atomic species with a single-photon optical clock transition. We calculate trajectories for our scheme that optimize the recoil phase while nullifying the undesired gravity-gradient phase by considering independently launching two clouds of ultracold atoms with the appropriate initial conditions. For Sr and Yb, we find an atom interferometer of height 3 m to be sufficient for an absolute mass measurement precision of π₯β’π/πβΌ1Γ10β11 with current technology. Such a precise measurement would halve the current uncertainty in πΌ β an uncertainty that would no longer be limited by an absolute mass measurement. The removal of this limitation would allow the current uncertainty in πΌ to be reduced by a factor of 10 by corresponding improvements in relative mass measurements, thus paving the way for higher-precision tests of the standard model of particle physics.